Thursday, November 19, 2026
63 °
Clear
Log in Subscribe

County board cuts tourism, boosts UW-Extension in 2027 budget

Posted

The Oneida County Board of Supervisors last week adopted a 2027 budget that eliminates county funding for tourism marketing, rejecting two separate attempts to restore $92,800 for the Oneida County Tourism Council, while voting unanimously to give UW-Extension an extra $10,000.

The budget, approved 15-5 with one supervisor absent, totals $76.93 million, a $2.37 million increase over this year’s $74.56 million budget. The total tax levy is $19,162,597.85, roughly a 2.1% increase, after supervisors unanimously added $618.85 for state chargebacks on refunded and rescinded taxes. Administrative Coordinator/County Clerk Tracy Hartman said the county learned of the chargeback on Nov. 9, after the budget had been published and one day before the county board meeting.

Board Chairman Scott Holewinski told the public hearing that the estimated county tax rate will fall from $1.44 per $1,000 of equalized value to $1.30, but cautioned that most tax bills will likely still rise because the county’s equalized valuation jumped 11.4% this year. Holewinski said the Executive Committee cut just under $4 million from department requests during three days of hearings in October to balance the budget, compared to about $1.3 million last year. The state levy limit, tied to net new construction, allowed only a 1.2% increase — $189,011 — while wage and benefit increases alone add about $1.2 million, he said.

Tourism

The tourism council’s funding was the only program eliminated outright in the proposed budget, according to Supervisor Billy Fried, who chairs the Executive Committee and made the motion to cut it during October’s hearings.

“I got some emails. I heard some comments. Billy doesn’t like tourism. I love tourism,” Fried said.

Fried said the committee chose to redirect roughly $90,000 that had gone to marketing into non-mandated services he said support visitors — sheriff’s department snowmobile, UTV and boat patrols, the Rhinelander-Oneida County Airport and economic development. He said the committee saw county tourism marketing as a duplication of efforts by local chambers and visitors bureaus, and invited the tourism council to come back with a specific project, as it did with a county recreation mapping project funded with COVID-relief money.

“When you look at the low-hanging fruit, it’s the non-mandated services,” Fried said.

Several tourism leaders urged the board to reverse course during the public hearing.

Krystal Westfahl, president and CEO of the Minocqua Area Visitors Bureau, said the county has invested about $100,000 a year in tourism promotion for more than a decade, and that visitor spending is already softening as consumers tighten their budgets. “When the market becomes more competitive, marketing becomes more important, not less,” she said.

Jacqui Sharpe, executive director of the Three Lakes Visitors Bureau and chair of the Oneida County Tourism Council, said state economic impact figures show one in every five sales tax dollars in Oneida County comes from direct visitor spending, and one in eight jobs is tied to tourism. She said 15 of the county’s 21 municipalities do not collect room tax and have no chamber or visitors bureau marketing them — the communities she said county tourism serves.

“Tourism marketing is an investment in that future sales tax revenue,” Sharpe said.

Lauren Sackett, CEO of the Rhinelander Area Chamber of Commerce and a new member of the tourism council, said the cut raises a bigger question about whether the county is willing to invest in its own economic competitiveness.

“Eliminating tourism funding sends a message about where we are willing to invest and where we aren’t,” she said.

Sales tax proposal fails

After the hearing, Supervisor Kyle Kilbourn moved to restore the tourism money by raising the county’s 2027 sales tax revenue estimate from $7.7 million to $7.8 million, based on a Forward Analytics forecast of about $7.866 million. Supervisor Mary Roth Burns seconded. Kilbourn said the budget process started by telling departments to expect a shortfall rather than by setting priorities.

“That’s the difference between balancing a budget and building a strategic budget,” he said, adding that the county closed a nearly $4 million gap largely through revenue adjustments, transfers and fund balance while cutting a “relatively narrow set” of programs. “Tourism is not just a line item.”

Supervisor Michael Tautges said the $7.7 million already assumes about a 5.4% increase and called it optimistic. He noted the area’s three main chambers and visitors bureaus collect well over $1 million a year in room tax to market tourism, and said county tourism funding is “broadly unnecessary.”

Fried said inflating revenue projections “will come back to bite us,” and that the cost would “snowball” into future budgets. He also cited the risk of losing state inmate revenue with a change in governor.

Supporters argued the county has routinely under-projected sales tax. One supervisor who said he runs a small business said that in recent years the county missed its sales tax projection only once, by 1%, and otherwise beat it by at least 3%. Supervisor Linnaea Newman said timber revenue is unreliable and that cutting tourism now could cost the county visitors and sales tax five years down the road. Supervisor Andrea Sheppard said it made little sense not to invest in a source of revenue. The motion failed 9-12. Kilbourn, Burns, Newman, Matt Campbell, Robb Jensen, Lenore Lopez, Collette Sorgel, Sheppard and Chris Schultz voted in favor.

Later in the meeting, a supervisor tried again, moving to fund the $92,800 by cutting the general fund contingency line, which finance director Heather Marheine said is budgeted at $250,000.

“Since you guys did not like the sales tax, let’s try another approach,” Kilbourn said.

That motion also failed.

UW-Extension fared better. Supervisors voted unanimously to raise its budget from $125,000 to $135,000, with the $10,000 coming from contingency. The supervisor who made the motion, speaking for the Conservation and UW-Extension Education Committee, said the county has cut at least two full-time Extension positions since he joined the board in 2014.

“Why do we want to decrease funding for an organization that is doing what we wanted it to do?” he said.

Another supervisor credited the Extension office’s director with eliminating duplicated services. During public comment, members of the Oneida County 4-H robotics program, part of Extension’s youth programming, lined up to support the department. Nolan, a team member, said the team recently won the Core Values Award at regionals in West Salem for the third year in a row and will compete at sectionals in Milwaukee.

Another member of the public noted that Oneida County was home to Wisconsin’s first county Extension partnership with the University of Wisconsin, beginning Feb. 12, 1912. He said the county gets more than double its roughly $130,000 investment back from the UW system — about 0.16% of the total budget.

Oneida County Board of Supervisors, tourism cuts, UW-Extension, 2027 budget

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here