Wednesday, November 18, 2026
57 °
Clear
Log in Subscribe

Redo vote cuts Rhinelander library budget 5%; county holds back funds

Posted

The Rhinelander District Library will get approximately $40,000 less from its member municipalities next year after a reconvened arbitration committee voted 4-1 Nov. 10 to set their combined 2027 contribution at $776,773.83. The Nov. 10 vote replaced the committee’s Oct. 27 decision, which had kept each municipality’s individual 2026 share unchanged for 2027. Library officials said that approach broke the district agreement, which lets the municipalities cut the library’s bottom line but requires the contract formula to decide what each one pays.

The City of Rhinelander cast the only no vote. Newbold, Pine Lake, Crescent and Pelican voted yes.

Earlier the same day, the Oneida County Board voted to hold back approximately $89,750 of the library’s county funding until it turns over financial records requested by the Town of Pine Lake.

Starting over

Newbold Town Chairman Dan Hess, chosen to chair the redo arbitration session, opened by moving to rescind his Oct. 27 motion. After that motion passed, Pine Lake Town Chairman Jim Flory moved to set the combined municipal share at $776,773.83.

Mayor Kris Hanus, representing Rhinelander, moved to amend the figure to the library’s 2026 total plus 3% but the amendment died for lack of a second.

“You’re asking a library organization to live within their budget of the same amount as last year. I don’t have one department that could do that,” he said. “You’re just delaying a bigger bill.”

He said the city’s budget, which the Common Council approved on Nov. 9, already reflects a reduction of about $22,000 in the city’s library payment. He also called the library “one of the last areas in our community where you can get knowledge for free.”

“It’s not free though,” Hess replied.

Who pays what

The cut to the total does not change every town’s bill by the same amount, because the contract formula is still applied. Half of each municipality’s share is based on equalized property value and half on population. When library trustee Eileen Daniel asked whether the town representatives understood that some of them would still pay more under the formula, the town reps confirmed they understood.

Library director Virginia Roberts said she would get the updated shares to the towns and the city before Thanksgiving. Officials noted that municipalities have until December to adopt their budgets.The 5% cut may not have been entirely unexpected as during the Nov. 3 meeting of the Board of Trustees Roberts advised that a town official had said on the way out of the Oct. 27 meeting that the towns would cut the library’s budget by 5%.

‘There’s no way’

As he did during the Oct. 27 meeting, Hess stressed that town budgets are strained. “When you have a budget share for the library at 17,000, and your net new construction for your towns is at 14,000, there’s no way we can come up with that money,” he said, He added that his town had to take $85,000 from its carryover account and asked how much the library holds in its own carryover accounts.

He suggested the library might have to cut a position or reduce some jobs to limited-term employment, as the towns and city have had to cut staff. Hanus said he did not want to do anything “rash.” He suggested approving a budget now and planning any staffing changes before next year’s budget cycle.

Hess also renewed his push for the library to use more volunteers.

Laura Tooke Effinger, a retired school library media specialist who serves as president of the library’s board of trustees, said the library does use volunteers: they run its year-round book sale and sometimes help with programs. She said volunteers can’t do work that exposes patron records, and many library jobs require training. She read notes from librarians in Merrill and Appleton who said their libraries also rely on few volunteers, mainly for book repair and book sales.

Daniel added that anyone working around the children who use the library has to be background checked and trained, an investment that can be lost if a volunteer leaves.

Hess also criticized Roberts, alleging she uttered a mild profanity during the Oct. 27 meeting “in violation of how we’re supposed to treat each other in here.” At the outset of both arbitration meetings, a long list of “ground rules” was recited setting forth expected decorum for the proceedings.

Roberts did not respond to Hess’s remarks during the meeting. When asked to comment later, she stated “they misheard.”

Records and communication

Hess said the town representatives have been frustrated by what they perceive as a lack of cooperation with respect to the production of requested records.

“If we would get more cooperation with your library director, I think the towns would be more interested in working with you,” he said.

Tooke Effinger said the library emails checkout numbers for each municipality every month. She said the library would put together a clearer packet if the towns specify what they want. Flory said Pine Lake gets updates on overall spending and the percentage of the budget left, but would like line-item detail.

Contract review ahead

Flory said the district agreement dates to 2005 and proposed that the municipalities begin rewriting it in December. Others pushed for January, noting the city’s new administrator, Angela Gorall, is about to take office. The group settled on 5:30 p.m. Jan. 5 at the Newbold Town Hall.

Hess said the review will involve the five municipalities that make up the library district (Crescent, Pelican, Pine Lake, Newbold and the City of Rhinelander) but will be an open meeting.

County withholds funds

As part of its budget meeting Tuesday morning, the Oneida County Board voted to withhold funding for the library above the 70% required by law until the records requested by the Town of Pine Lake are provided.

The motion by Supervisor Mary Roth Burns, who represents Pine Lake, adopted a proposal presented during public comment by Pine Lake Town Supervisor Ron Lueneburg. Lueneburg said the town has struggled for more than a year to obtain the records. The library must provide current signed copies of all rental agreements for buildings it owns, a detailed 2025 financial statement including lapsing and non-lapsing accounts, and a 2026 list of all paid positions with employee names, wages, hours and vacancies. The deadline for production of the records is Dec. 31.

County board chair Scott Holewinski noted the Rhinelander library is funded at 127% compared to a state average of 100%. According to a spreadsheet obtained from the county, the Rhinelander library’s request to the county for 2027 was for $199,852. If the requested documents are not received by the deadline or are determined by the board to be insufficient only $110,100.55 will be disbursed, according to county administrative coordinator Tracy Hartman.

Supervisors first amended the motion, 20-0, so the full county board, rather than the Executive Committee, will review the records and decide whether to release the remaining money. One supervisor had objected that the original plan took the decision away from most members.

Hartman said the withheld money would still be levied and held in a separate library fund. If the records aren’t produced, it would roll into 2027 and offset next year’s library request, similar to how the county handles its ambulance fund.

The amended motion passed 19-1, with Supervisor Kyle Kilbourn voting no and one supervisor absent. The hold applies only to the Rhinelander library; Corporation Counsel Chad Lynch said state statute treats county payments to each library separately so the Minocqua and Three Lakes libraries will be unaffected.

The county board’s motion was not mentioned during the evening arbitration meeting but Roberts confirmed she was aware of the board’s directive and was gathering information. She indicated the request will likely need to go through the Oneida County Library Board. That group met Thursday afternoon at which time it was mentioned that the exact wording of the motion will need to be obtained from the county clerk.

Library expansion project

Fundraising is ongoing for the planned renovation and expansion of the library, according to both Roberts and Tooke Effinger.

“As a board, there has been no discussion of putting the expansion/renovation project on hold and the space occupied by the rental properties is part of the overall expansion plan,” Tooke Effinger said in response to a question from the Star Journal. “We are still actively fundraising and our volunteers are working hard to build long term relationships with individuals, families and corporations who can help us toward our goal of creating more usable and accessible space for our community and our visitors.”

Redo vote, Rhinelander library, budget cuts, fund held back

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here